With pick #2 take whoever is left out of A-Rod and Hanley Ramirez assuming Pujols doesn't go #1. If he does, take whoever you want to root for more.
It's hard to say who to go for after that since I don't know who will be available or who you already have on your team. Get Ryan Howard or Chase Utley is they are there at #25. Utley is more likely to be. Maybe Longoria? Hard to say man.